Friday, September 4, 2020

263: Asimov Vs Doyle

 Audio Link


Reading Isaac Asimov’s essay collection “The Roving Mind”, I was surprised to see some rather harsh comments aimed at Sherlock Holmes author Arthur Conan Doyle.   Asimov didn’t have any issues with the quality of the fiction, but was pointing out some scientific errors in Doyle’s writing.   Some of his most severe comments were aimed at the fact that the evil Professor Moriarty was presented as a mathematical genius, and said to have written “a treatise on the binomial theorem”.   Here are Asimov’s comments on that credential:


Moriarty was 21 years old in 1865 (it is estimated), but forty years earlier than that the Norwegian mathematician Niels Henrik Abel had fully worked out the last detail of the mathematical subject known as “the binomial theorem,” leaving Moriarty nothing to do on the matter. It was completely solved and has not advanced beyond Abel to this day.

Asimov, Isaac. The Roving Mind (p. 141). Prometheus Books - A. Kindle Edition. 


Is this really true?  Did Asimov land a slam dunk against poor Doyle, forever disproving his mathematical competence, and casting doubt on the talents of evil genius Moriarty?   Well, let’s take a closer look.


First, let’s refresh our memories on the Binomial Theorem.   Most simply viewed, this is a theorem that talks about the coefficients of the terms when you expand the expression (x + y) taken to the nth power.    For example, x + y to the 1st power has the exponents 1 1 , since there is 1 x and 1 y.   If you square x + y, you get x^2 + 2xy + y^2, so the exponents are 1 2 1.  Continuing further, if you cube it the exponents are 1 3 3 1.    If you write out these exponents in rows, each one staggered so the middle terms appear between two numbers above, you get the famous construct known as Pascal’s Triangle.  Aside from the diagonal sets of 1s going down the left and right edges, each number in the triangle is the sum of the two numbers above.   The 2 in the second row is the sum of the 2 1s above it, the 3s in the 3rd row are each the sum of a 1 and 2 above, etc.   The binomial theorem basically states that Pascal’s Triangle correctly represents the coefficients for any exponential power of (x+y).


I have, as usual, oversimplified a bit here.   If you write out a few examples, you’ll quickly see that in the form I just stated, the theorem seems to just fall out naturally from the way algebra works.   It’s pretty easy to prove by simple induction.    And in fact, limited cases have been understood since the 4th century A.D.   But once you allow non-integer or irrational exponents, the theorem becomes a lot more complex.   As Asimov stated, Niels Abel is credited with proving a generalized version of the theorem in the 1820s, as part of an amazing streak of mathematical contributions before his untimely death at the age of 27.   


But does this mean that Asimov is correct, and Moriarty could not have demonstrated his mathematical talents with a treatise on this theorem?   The most ironic aspect of Asimov’s comments, I think, is the lack of self-reflection.   After all, what are Asimov’s essay collections?   Essentially he is writing about well-established areas of science and mathematics, to improve their understanding by the general public.   Nearly every one of his essays covers facts that were discovered and/or proven many years before he wrote.   Indeed, if I comment indirectly about this exact work by writing “Asimov was a great essayist, and I enjoyed his commentary in ‘The Roving Mind’ about the binomial theorem”, would that invalidate my own credentials, as I can’t possibly praise someone’s expository writing about a well-established theorem?


Here’s one way to brush aside that quibble:  perhaps Asimov was implicitly considering popular essays about science and math, like his books or like the Math Mutation podcast, to be intellectually trivial exercises, not indicating any particular intelligence by the author.   I’ll refrain from further comment in that domain from a motive of self-preservation.   But even assuming we accept that judgement for now, I think Asimov made a deeper error here.   


In mathematics, you are never really “done”.   There are nearly always ways to improve or generalize a theorem.   Can we apply it to vectors, matrixes, or fields?   Can we apply it to general types of functions other than the algebraic expressions Abel originally considered?   Can we find analogs of the theorem that apply to powers of more complex expressions, or in higher-dimensional spaces?   While Abel may have definitively proven the theorem as originally stated, that was far from the end of possible work in related areas.    A little web searching, in fact, uncovers a 2011 paper by modern-era mathematician David Goss called “The Ongoing Binomial Revolution”, which discusses several major 20th century mathematical results that descend from the Binomial Theorem.   I’d like to provide more details, but I’m afraid most of the paper is a bit over my head.   However, it ends with a telling comment:   “Future research should lead to a deeper understanding of these recent offshoots of the Binomial Theorem as well as add many, as yet undiscovered, new ones.”


It looks like Asimov himself, while a very intelligent man and a great writer, held a somewhat naive view of mathematics.    It’s a common mistake, often made by people in applied fields who have always consumed math as well-established, fully presented theorems and formulas.   We need to recognize that a huge part of the genius of mathematics is the idea of abstracting and generalizing previous observations, and this work never really stops.   When a theorem is proven, that usually leads to even more opportunities for offshoots, generalizations, and other further expansion of knowledge.    Thus, I think we have to conclude that Isaac Asimov was wrong, and it was perfectly reasonable for an academic to write meaningfully about the Binomial Theorem many years after Abel, like Goss in his 2011 paper.     Holmes was right to fear Moriarty, as there is nothing more dangerous than an archvillian who understands mathematics.  


And this has been your math mutation for today.



References:  

24 comments:

  1. Are you looking for instant approval directory submission sites list 2021 ? Here is the list of instant approval directory sites can help you to make increase website authority and get backlinks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Best skin care clinic bengaluru, Karnataka - If you are looking for the Best skin care clinic in bengaluru, karnataka, Dr. Praveen Bhardwaj is the best dermatologist doctor for skin care clinic at affordable cost.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Best web designing companies in noida - Prashi Digitech is one of the leading web development Company in Noida. It offers Web design, web development and digital marketing services in affordable prices.

    ReplyDelete

  4. Book sensuous south ex Vip Call Girls in your choice

    We have lots of different kinds of profiles and we are providing South ex escorts for a long time. We basically deal with the high profile Escorts who can fulfill all the requirements of the clients. These young South ex Call Girls In here Fulfill your all intimacy fantasies and these VIP ladies are super sexy and have a perfect body.

    South ex call girl services

    ReplyDelete
  5. Book Udaipur beautiful female to fulfill your physical needs

    We basically deal with the Udaipur high profile Escorts who can fulfill all the requirements of the clients. A place known where every kind of female escorts like Independent, russain,models, Elite high professional and the most awesome udaipur hot escorts are being offered through our agency.So without any hesitation call or whatsapp

    Udaipur escorts

    ReplyDelete
  6. In case you are examining and Lajpat Nagar Escorts looking for good conditions which not simply fill your heart with satisfaction and night without making any single flood. Kalkaji Escorts at that point, you have connected to the right page where your beginning and end kind of need have the best coordinate with us in your moderate range. Ashram Escorts We do all possible individual help from start to finish where you are stacked with extraordinary conditions and free with your chips for an amazing duration Paharganj Escorts.

    Lajpat Nagar Escorts Service
    Kalkaji Escorts Service
    Ashram Escorts Service
    Paharganj Escorts service

    ReplyDelete
  7. The time has come to explore the quality of mature sex when you are a beginner. Yes, this opportunity is available in the form of Desi Indian Bhabhi Escorts in Green Park services. These girls are impressive for the bold sex and the bold sex gives your ability to stay for a long time in the bedroom always.

    Green Park Escorts Service
    Green Park Escorts Service
    Green Park Escorts Service
    Green Park Escorts Service
    Green Park Escorts Service

    ReplyDelete
  8. The call girls are masters can provide a higher level of satisfaction. Are you looking for the Desi Indian Bhabhi Escorts in Rajouri Garden? The reason to look at these services is satisfaction level because people are looking for mature services for the booking of escorts because they want to make sure sexual satisfaction is always higher with these Call Girl Services in Rajouri Garden.

    Rajouri Garden Escorts Service
    Rajouri Garden Escorts Service
    Rajouri Garden Escorts Service
    Rajouri Garden Escorts Service
    Rajouri Garden Escorts Service
    Rajouri Garden Escorts Service

    ReplyDelete
  9. The company of Mayur Vihar Escorts is one of the great ways to add charm and beauty to your life. Book us now...

    ReplyDelete
  10. Online Grow Business Provide All Digital marketing services like SEO, SMO, Web Desing & Development, PPC and Mobile App & all your queries Like How To, Tech News Tips.
    Online Grow Business
    seo services
    smo Services
    Digital Marketing services
    Web Design development
    Mobile App Development
    PPC Services
    Directory submission
    Blog Commenting sites links

    ReplyDelete

  11. Find Best Escorts and Call Girls At Schloka. Here Your Can Post Escorts category Ads and Get Best Business. We Alow To Post ads in all Over India Cities. and You Can Also Find Best Escort Girls Here.

    Schloka Escorts Rajkot
    Schloka Escorts Tapi
    Schloka Escorts Valsad
    Schloka Escorts Ambala
    Schloka Escorts Bhiwani

    ReplyDelete
  12. Incredible Article! I truly Value your work. Thanks for sharing this well-informed blog post. Many thanks for sharing. Classified Websites List in India.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Amazing and valuable content you shared with us keep it up with amazing and interesting content.
    Kill addiction dawa

    ReplyDelete
  14. We are Delhi based SMO Company, We offer Social Media Optimization (SMO) Services in Delhi, India at reasonable price
    Emotions Interior Designer is the most textured interior design. their company provide a unique and creative approach to their customers.
    buy money plant online at best prices only at Birthright, India's leading online shop for agriculture supplies and garden tools.
    Financeatyourtip, provide updates about the best demat account for traders all over world. Its brokerage fee is extremely feasible and this assists traders and investors
    F95zone Latest Games & Updates. A visual overview of the latest new games and updates.buy indoor plants online at best prices only at Birthright, India's leading online shop.

    ReplyDelete
  15. We are Delhi based SEO Company, We offer SEO Company In Rohini, Delhi at reasonable price
    Emotions Interior Designer is the most interior designers in Gorakhpur, India. their company provide a unique and creative approach to their customers.
    Buy Aloe Vera Indoor Plant Online In India at best prices only at Birthright, India's leading online shop for agriculture supplies and garden tools.
    Financeatyourtip, provide updates about the best demat account for traders all over world. Its brokerage fee is extremely feasible and this assists traders and investors
    F95zone Latest Games & Updates. A visual overview of the latest new games and updates.Buy Money Plant Online in India at best prices only at Birthright, India's leading online shop.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Very helpful post you shared with us be continue...
    bhagavad gita quotes in hindi

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nice blog, thank you so much for sharing this informative blog. I love this website.
    2D floor design plans

    ReplyDelete
  18. Buy the best weight loss supplements in UAE that help to shed muscle to become slimmer.
    best online herbal shop in Dubai

    FITNE HERBAL INFUSION SLIMMING TEA IN DUBAI

    ReplyDelete
  19. The article is very interesting and very understood to be read, may be useful for the people.
    Car body repair shop dandenong

    ReplyDelete
  20. I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to undertand.
    best backwater resorts in kollam

    ReplyDelete
  21. Our spa center provides best skilled hot massage girls to treat your body aches and pains, so you can come and take our best services for your good health
    b2b massage in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  22. female to male spa near me is one of the classic place in Bangalore for spa therapies

    ReplyDelete
  23. You can come and take spa services from massage spa near me center, then you forget your all tension and mind tress

    ReplyDelete