## Saturday, November 30, 2019

### 256: Crazy Eyed Fish

In the last episode I talked a bit about Richard Dawkins’s book “Climbing Mount Improbable”, explaining how arguments about the mathematical impossibility of evolution tend to overlook some details of how it actually works.   Today we’re going to talk about another interesting mathematical aspect of evolution that Dawkins discusses in that book, the rise of symmetry.  We all know that most modern animals seem to mostly exhibit symmetry along at least one axis.  Some have argued that this is evidence of intelligent planning, similar to a computer-based CAD design done with attention to appearance, beauty, or other subjective standards.   But actually, if you think about how evolution works, there are several natural selection pressures which would inherently push multicellular creatures towards symmetry as they evolve.

One of the most basic observations is that if you’re a creature that simply floats in the water, is anchored to a point on the ground, or doesn’t move much, you have a natural notion of “up” and “down”, but most other directions are equivalent.   Up is the place where sunlight comes from, while Down is the direction where gravity pulls you.   Aside from this distinction, you don’t want to favor particular other directions, since you don’t know where your food will happen to come from.   So if you evolve some useful new feature, like a starfish’s arms, the most efficient design will equally space them around you, enabling their use in all directions.   A natural form of mutation is to duplicate a body part.   These simple observations result in the radial symmetry we see in creatures like jellyfish and starfish.

In the case of creatures that intentionally move for a while in a consistent direction, new factors come into play.   You still have the natural concepts of up and down, since the sun and gravity are almost always going to be critical factors.   But now whenever you are moving, you also have a definite direction of motion, usually towards your food.   Thus you want to have a mouth at one end, and your waste disposal method at the other, so you leave your waste behind rather than wasting energy uselessly re-eating it.    But the directions perpendicular to your motion, the left and right, are still essentially equivalent, so biasing your body in favor of one side would be disadvantageous, or even lead to pulling you around in circles if it affects your method of movement.

I think the most interesting examples of evolution are the rare exceptions to the above rules, where a formerly symmetric animal finds benefits in breaking that symmetry.   For example, flatfish like flounders and sole look pretty bizarre to us, as they lie on the bottom of the water with both eyes facing upward, one in the “proper” location and the other oddly misplaced on the fish’s face.   They evolved from typical symmetric, nice-looking fish that swam vertically in the water, and in fact are born in a similar form.   But when some of them developed a behavioral mutation and discovered they could feed efficiently by laying on the bottom, selection pressure gradually created mechanisms that moved the now useless bottom eye around to the top as the fish grows.   The resulting arrangement is bizarre-looking due to its asymmetry, but of course quite functional for the fish.   And remembering our discussion in the last episode, how evolution must proceed from very small, not-too-improbable steps:  a series of mutations that gradually move the existing eye to an awkward but functional position is much more likely than a lucky, almost impossible mutation that would rearrange the eyes to symmetrical positions on top of the fish.

And of course, we can’t forget the many cases where a useful body feature doesn’t directly affect a creature’s interaction with the outside world, so can evolve asymmetrically with no problem.   How many medical comedies have you seen on TV with a cliche situation where someone starts to cut on the wrong side to remove someone’s appendix?   We actually have many internal organs in asymmetric positions— in fact, to a designer who valued the beauty of symmetry, human (and most animal) internal organ arrangements are a total mess.    Maybe in a few years we’ll understand DNA well enough to redesign ourselves in a nice, truly symmetric, pattern.

And this has been your math mutation for today.

References:

1. Did you know there's a 12 word sentence you can tell your partner... that will trigger intense emotions of love and instinctual appeal to you buried inside his heart?

Because hidden in these 12 words is a "secret signal" that fuels a man's instinct to love, cherish and protect you with all his heart...

12 Words Who Fuel A Man's Love Impulse

This instinct is so hardwired into a man's mind that it will make him work harder than ever before to build your relationship stronger.

Matter-of-fact, triggering this influential instinct is so essential to achieving the best possible relationship with your man that the second you send your man one of these "Secret Signals"...

...You'll soon notice him open his soul and mind for you in such a way he haven't experienced before and he'll recognize you as the only woman in the universe who has ever truly appealed to him.

2. Really i appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge.Private tutor Highland Beach The topic here i found was really effective to the topic which i was researching for a long time

3. Thanks a lot for sharing. SAT Tutor Gulf Stream Will check back later for more of your articles.

4. I would very much like to agree with the previous commenter! I find this blog really useful for my uni project. Private tutor Lighthouse I hope to add more useful posts later.

5. Here i found nice environment to get new ideas and views and the i have read the comments of this blog Jupiter Island Tutoring and these are really nice and it is glad to comment here.

6. Here i found nice environment to get new ideas and views and the i have read the comments of this blog Jupiter Island Tutoring and these are really nice and it is glad to comment here.

7. Here i found nice environment to get new ideas and views and the i have read the comments of this blog Jupiter Island Tutoring and these are really nice and it is glad to comment here.

8. A mind blowing article is provided here. Wellington Tutoring And it is written with great skill and the words directly explain the thought of author.

9. Thank you for the work you have put into your nice blog. Palm Beach Tutoring We will bookmark to your blog because it is very informational. We love the site and will come back to see your new posts.

10. Thanks for give me information on this topic. Boynton Beach Tutoring you have sharing very nice post.

11. It seems like an educational blog which always some new information to visitors Parkland Tutoring and Enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

12. A mind blowing article is provided here. St. Petersburg Tutoring And it is written with great skill and the words directly explain the thought of author.

13. I really enjoyed reading this post, I always appreciate topics like this being discussed to us. St. Augustine Tutoring Thanks for sharing.

14. I really enjoyed reading this post, I always appreciate topics like this being discussed to us. Special needs Tutor Westport Thanks for sharing.

15. This is really informative blog for students, Special needs Tutor Larchmont keep up the good work.

16. Thanks for give me information on this topic. Special needs Tutor Greenwich you have sharing very nice post.

17. I’ve desired to post about something similar to this on one of my blogs and this has given me an idea. Special needs Tutor Wellesley Cool Mat.

18. Good information here. I really enjoy reading them every day. I've learned a lot from them.Special needs tutor Sag Harbor Thanks so much for sharing this information. Greatly help me being a newbie.